The Department of Economic and Community Development’s (DECD) argument that statutory rules for assessing per-page-copying fees for paper records requested under Connecticut’s Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) allow agencies to assess fees to recoup costs associated with the production of records in any type of request, even electronic, is “misguided,” “unsupported,” and a “tortured analysis” of statute, according to a brief by the Freedom of Information Commission (FOIC).

The FOIC recently submitted their defense brief in a pending case before the New Britain Appeals Court, in which DECD is challenging a ruling by the commission rejecting a fee estimate of over $40,000.

In April 2025, DECD quoted Adam Osmond, a former employee turned whistleblower against the agency, $41,943.25 for the production of 167,773 pages of records that Osmond requested electronically and which only exist in electronic form. At the time, DECD maintained that the fee was determined by multiplying the number of pages by the copying fee of up to 25 cents per page FOIA authorizes state agencies to charge to cover costs associated with the production of copies of paper records.

Later, DECD officials told Osmond the basis for the fee was to cover the time employees had to spend reviewing and redacting responsive records. DECD also told Osmond on multiple occasions that they would not process the request until they received payment and, if he provided only partial payment, they would only partially fulfill the request.

While FOIA does allow agencies to ask fees over $10 be paid up front, the FOIC found that DECD violated FOIA by “conditioning receipt of the requested records on the prepayment of the complainant’s prepayment of exorbitant fees.”

At issue in the case is Sec. 1-212 of state statute, which outlines the specific cases in which agencies can assess fees for copies of electronic records.

“In determining such costs for a copy, other than for a printout which exists at the time that the agency responds to the request for such copy, an agency may include only,” the cost of a storage device, such as a thumb drive; computer time charges incurred when an agency must use a contractor to access requested records; an amount equal to the cost of engaging a professional copying service, if necessary; or “[a]n amount equal to the hourly salary attributed to all agency employees engaged in providing the requested computer-stored public record, including their time performing the formatting or programming functions necessary to provide the copy as requested, but not including search or retrieval costs.”

DECD officials appealed the FOIC’s ruling, arguing the statute’s construction of the per-page copying fee for electronic records does not just reflect the cost of paper and toner, but also of employee labor, and this means it can also charge for electronic records.

DECD’s brief outlining their case, filed in June, notes that Sec. 1-212 applies to the “fee for any copy,” which they argue means fees are not determined by the format in which they are provided.

“Thus, the fee is in no way contingent upon the copy requested and provided being copy paper, and accordingly should not be understood as a reimbursement fee for the expense of purchasing pieces of photocopy paper.” Assistant Attorney General John Langmaid, who has represented DECD throughout the case, writes in the agency’s brief.

DECD cites a 2008 appeals court case, which found that “page,” as referred to in the FOI statute, refers to each side of the piece of paper on which information is printed. This, DECD argues, means the up to 25 cents per-page fee state agencies can charge for paper records is “plainly unrelated to the agency’s actual paper and toner expenses.”

“Rather, the flat fee reimburses any of the agency’s expenses of providing copies of paper records, which will include labor costs identifying and removing exempt information from copies.” Langmaid wrote.

The brief further states that the primary issue is over the portion of statute that allows agencies to charge for time employees spend programming and formatting records, but not search or retrieval costs.

“The only exception to the labor expense is the labor while engaged in “search or retrieval” of the original digital record. Completely absent is any explicit reference to “legal review,” “preparing,” “collating,” “identifying exempt data,” “reviewing,” or “redacting.” Yet all these acts of labor are foreseeable labor that an agency employee may need to perform while “engaged in providing” copies, subsequent to the search and retrieval of the digital record(s) requested.” Langmaid writes.

He adds that because the copying process includes search and retrieval, the statute’s prohibition on charging for time employees spend searching for and retrieving records “plainly refers to the pre-copying search and retrieval process.”

In its recently filed brief, the FOIC reiterated its arguments that DECD officials are rewriting statute.

“The plaintiffs read “engaged in providing” as affording them carte blanche to charge for every part of processing a records request, except for “search and retrieval” costs. Ironically, they include time spent withholding public records through making redactions, reasoning that they must remove information they believe is exempt before providing a document. In so arguing, it is clear that the plaintiffs fundamentally misunderstand the meaning of a public record.” Nicholas Smarra wrote in the FOIC’s brief.

The commission also argues that public agencies’ ability to charge for time spent reviewing and redacting records would “obstruct the Commission’s adjudication of claimed exemptions” and the ability of courts to review them and “enable public agencies to arbitrarily differentiate between charges for reviewing paper and computer stored records.”

“Under the plaintiff’s construction of the Act’s fee provisions, an agency could predicate a fee estimate on its belief, without review or examination, that records contain exempt information, then refuse to review the records until a requester pays the agency’s fee demand.” the FOIC’s brief states, noting the burden to prove an exemption applies is on the agency claiming it.

“The plaintiffs’ position literally requires requesters to pay an agency to substantiate its own claimed exemptions. The review and redaction necessary to justify withholding information are, in substance, the agency’s legal work undertaken to meet its burden of proving that the claimed exemptions apply.” the commission’s brief continued.

Osmond also recently filed a brief, which states that DECD official’s brief mischaracterizes and omits several facts, including conflating two separate requests and leaving out correspondence in which Osmond offered to narrow the terms of his request.

Osmond’s complaint against DECD is not the only pending appeal in which various state agencies, represented by the attorney general’s office, are attempting to argue that the FOI statute allows agencies to charge hourly fees.

The FOIC has also ruled against the attorney general’s office, in another complaint brought by Osmond; the Office of Policy and Management, and the Office of the Healthcare Advocate. Appeals in those cases, except for the FOIC’s ruling against the OHA, are pending.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

An advocate for transparency and accountability, Katherine has over a decade of experience covering government. Her work has won several awards for defending open government, the First Amendment, and shining...

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *