Deep River Connecticut First Selectman Carol Doak-Jones issued a press release on November 12 citing concerns over a story published by Inside Investigator about an ethics complaint submitted by town selectwoman Cynthia Torres requesting the town’s Ethics Commission investigate any connections between her fellow selectman Duane Gates and a longtime contractor for the town.
“Because the Ethics Commission’s review is ongoing, based upon meeting minutes visible on the Town’s website, there is concern that the complaint has been made public,” Doak-Jones said. “This is not in compliance with the procedures of the Ethics Commission or Connecticut General Statutes Section 7-148h. The Commission maintains that it did not publicly release the complaint document. This matter remains under review pursuant to the State Law and the Ethics Commission proceedings.”
Gates had previously recused himself from voting on a contract between the town and Running Brook Farms, which has had multiple contracts with the town, including one for on-going work at Plattwood Park, part of project funded by a state grant. Gates has previously stated that he is “friends” with the owner of the company, Scott Papoosha, and has performed volunteer work with them.
The complaint, submitted by Torres, questions whether Gates’ relationship with Running Brook Farms constitutes a conflict of interest and asks that the Ethics Commission investigate the matter. Torres claims Gates has “oversight” of some of the contracts with Running Brook Farms, an allegation that both Gates and Doak-Jones rejected.
Gates denies any claim that there is a conflict of interest between his service on the Board of Selectmen and the town’s ongoing work with Running Brook Farms.
Papoosha’s real estate company, Papoosha Real Estate LLC, was also the subject of public concerns voiced at a Planning and Zoning Commission meeting over the company’s clearing of land to create a Christmas tree farm. Gates indicated that insinuations were made during that meeting regarding his relationship with Running Brook Farms.
In her press release, Doak-Jones stated that publication of the complaint was “not in compliance” with the town’s Ethics Commission procedures, nor state statute.
According to those procedures, ethics complaints and investigations are to remain confidential unless the Commission determines that probable cause exists. If there is probable cause, the Commission will release the complaint and investigation and schedule a hearing.
A vote that there is probable cause or an ethical violation requires four out of the five members. The Deep River Ethics Commission procedures and ordinances mirror that of the Office of State Ethics, which is defined in state statute.
Deep River’s municipal ethics code indicates a conflict of interest can include an individual with a financial interest in a public matter or a personal interest — defined as “any interest, other than Financial Interest which would affect the action of the official or employee, except if that interest is based primarily on the responsibility of their town office or employment.”
According to the town ethics code, “Persons Governed by this Code shall not have a Financial Interest or Personal Beneficial Interest in any contract or purchase order for supplies, materials, equipment, or contractual services furnished or used by the board, agency or commission of which that person is a member, or an employee.”
The code goes on to state that no individual with a financial or personal beneficial interest – or whose family has a financial or personal beneficial interest – in a contract or services cannot vote on or participate in discussions on that matter. Membership in an organization, association, or nonprofit is not considered a personal interest unless the individual is an employee of that organization.
The regularly scheduled November 10 meeting of the Deep River Board of Selectmen was cancelled following Inside Investigator’s story due to a “meeting conflict resulting in a lack of quorum. The Ethics Commission is scheduled to meet on November 18 to continue examining the complaint.
“Transparency, accountability and public confidence in our municipal institution are important to the health of our community,” Doak-Jones said in the press release. “Ethics complaints are only allegations, not substantiated findings. Hopefully, we as a community can remember this, as the integrity and effectiveness of our town’s Ethics Commission depends upon it.”


