After failing to follow up with several individuals who filed Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests, the Derby Police Department has been fined $250.

The fine came after the Freedom of Information Commission (FOIC) found the department did not respond to or conduct a search for records after Cordaryl Silva submitted a FOIA request. A final decision by the FOIC in a complaint submitted by Silva following Derby police’s lack of response noted that this was not the first time the department had ignored a request. This led the commission to fine the department.

At the center of the case was a December 2, 2023 FOIA request submitted by Silva to Derby police which sought the following: dispatch and radio transmission recordings associated with the May 12, 20112 homicide investigation of Javon Zimmerman, documents detailing when two detectives clocking in on May 12, 2012 to begin investigating the Zimmerman homicide, data the department took from a phone owned by Silva, and all notes taken by Derby police officers about the investigation into Zimmerman’s homicide.

Internally, when the department received Silva’s ‘request, they found it was identical to another request he had previously submitted and for which all responsive documents had been released.

But, according to the FOIC’s decision, the department took no other action. They did not send Silva any acknowledgment they had received the request. They also did not inform Silva that all records associated with the request had been previously released.

Silva appealed their failure to respond on December 14, 2023, and asked that a civil penalty of up to $1,000 be assessed against the department.

During hearings held on the complaint, Derby police acknowledged that they had not communicated with Silva about the request, but maintained they had “previously provided the complainants with all records related to the Zimmerman homicide investigation in response to his prior records requests.”

To support this, the department relied on evidence submitted by Silva showing previous correspondence with the department. But, as the decision adopted by the FOIC notes, those prior requests do not establish that they covered the same time and records as Silva’s December 3 request.

The decision further noted that “case law makes clear that a public agency is not absolved of its obligations to provide responsive records simply because a requestor has previously requested and received the same records.”

“Indeed, a complainant may seek to start an appeal period over again by asking for a record again, or a complainant may have lost the document after the first request.” the decision notes.

Therefore, the FOIC concluded, Derby police did not fulfill their obligation under FOIA to respond to Silva’s December 3 request. The decision also disputed the department’s assertion that they had conducted a diligent search for records because they provided no evidence showing the scope of the search or whether that scope was “reasonable in light of how such records are maintained by the respondents.” The decision also found the department did not search for records responsive to Silva’s December 3 request until after the hearing officer in the complaint issued an order to submit additional evidence on October 24, 2024.

The FOIC not only found that the Derby police department violated FOIA by failing to respond to the request but found this was not the first time they had done so. In another case from 2023, the commission found the police department acknowledged a request from Salvatore Coppola for an investigation report but never followed up with any communication and did not conduct a thorough investigation for the requested records.

The FOIC found Silva’s “right to prompt access to non-exempt responsive records” was denied by the police department without reasonable grounds, warranting a civil penalty. They ordered Derby police to conduct a thorough search for records within 14 days and to provide them free of charge. They also ordered the department to contact the FOIC to schedule FOIA training and to pay a $250 civil penalty within 30 days.

A lawyer for the police department objected to several portions of the finding during the FOIC’s November 20 meeting, including the requirement that documents be turned over within 14 days. They noted that several categories of the records did not exist. The attorney also asked that FOIA training be done by the police department’s office rather than by the FOIC due to recent turnover within the upper levels of the police department.

They also objected to the penalty on the grounds that Silva had previously received the documents and because city officials had to make several trips to the FOIC for hearings that Silva did not attend.

Asked by commissioners during the meeting if the fact that Silva had previously submitted the same request was a factor in the case, the hearing officer responded that the responsive records being exactly the same could not be verified. He added that the department’s “unilateral disregard” of the request should trigger the penalty in his mind, as well as how recently the similar circumstances of Coppola’s request had occurred. According to the hearing officer, the penalty assessed was on the lower end of the spectrum because there were only two instances of the department disregarding requests. The FOIC can assess penalties of up to $5,000.

The commission ultimately adopted the hearing officer’s recommendations, making a minor change to specify how the department could appropriately withhold records.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

An advocate for transparency and accountability, Katherine has over a decade of experience covering government. Her work has won several awards for defending open government, the First Amendment, and shining...

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *